Most of the time, we plug a studio monitor/speaker in and expect we’re going to get a great representation of what has been recorded. But if you don’t understand how a speaker works, you may be surprised how inaccurate your speakers are. In this article we’ll briefly cover the 3 things you need to know about one of the most critical characteristics of a speaker: Transient Response.
I Can’t Care Less About Silly Sound People Stuff!
Yeah. I get it. You just want to make movies. That’s what “audio people” are for. I understand. You’re probably editing on a laptop and listening to your mixes from the built in speakers, right? Applying music, sound effects and other things which sound great to you on your computer speakers, and then when you get them to your “audio guy’s” place, you berate them because they’ve obviously “done something to my sounds, because that’s not how they sound on my system!”
Sound Familiar? How about to you audio folks? Yeah. Thought so.
Here’s the thing: I’m not trying to be a jerk, but 85% of the independent filmmakers I bump into do their work on horrible speakers thinking that getting

good speakers is 1. too expensive, 2. unnecessary, 3. doesn’t affect the nature of the project. None of these are true. I talk about the kind of speakers to get as an entry level way to get a much more “true” representation of what you’re dumping in your timeline in the MZed Pro Member Education and across posts on this blog. Generally, you’re looking at the JBL LSR 305s. Why? They’re cheap, they’re portable, they sound great, and they have a great “transient response” down to about 60 Hz (which is pretty good). If you don’t have a good listening environment (and don’t talk to me about headphones), how can you possibly expect to up your production’s game and support your post audio guys to win? You do want them to win, right? If I had a $1 for every time I heard someone tell me in a studio environment they had no idea their dialog was so messed up – and if they’d known they’d have hired someone for $250/day to fix it instead of having to deal with it on the mix stage at $1,800/day…
Yes, this is silly sound people stuff, which, once you get a glimpse of it, will save your production thousands of dollars in audio post. Trust me. Read on. It’s a little more technical than usual, but it’ll also help you in your home theater system purchase as well.
Alright. Maybe I’ll Learn What Transient Response is. Maybe.
Great. Thanks for trusting me. The deal is this: the voltage coming out of your audio interface represents the sound you’re expecting hear coming out of your computer’s DAW/NLE. That voltage can be super erratic, and vibrates at tens of thousands of times a second. To reproduce that, you have to have some physical object which can not only respond that quickly and that with intense velocity every second, but it also must be able to jump instantly from one position to another in microseconds. Naturally, there’s no such object or material in the world which can do that perfectly. When you look at a speaker or a tweeter dome, they’re basically just pieces of thick paper or polymer suspended in rubber and pushed by a magnet. I can tell you, plastic/paper/polymer doesn’t really want to move fast, and it takes a whole lot more engineering to get a great sounding speaker than you’d ever imagine…and it’s easy to get a bad one. Transient Response is a fundamental characteristic of every speaker (and transducer) which will make or break your ability to have your mixes and audio translate.

What is it then? Simply: how fast can a speaker react and recover from a voltage stimulus.
What the heck does that mean?
Imagine you’ve got a nice happy speaker at rest. You think it’d be fun to slam a 100 dB voltage spike into it just to see what it’ll do. You’re a sadist. I understand. The voltage crashes into the magnet at the speed of light and the magnet responds in kind with a massive surge of EM force at the speed of light. The driver of the speaker is connected to the piece of paper we call the “speaker” (but is only the part you see). It reacts to the magnetic force and begins pushing the physical speaker forward. This is called the “Rise Time:” The time it takes to get from rest to the desired 100 dB amplitude. Now, this magnetic force is unflinching and accelerates the cone constantly until it reaches the 100 dB desired amplitude. Like a car trying to do the 1/4 mile. It’s hammer-down until the checkered flag…but then what happens? The voltage only pushed it to 100dB. Then the speaker continues to travel because of its inertia. It starts slowing down, sure, because it’s attached to a rubber mounting which wants it to go back to rest and other physical concerns. But what’s happening during this phase is the sound you’re expecting to hear is being distorted. The voltage did want the speaker to go to the “extra distance” it is, and the cone is still pushing air – and continuing the sound creation in a way not meant to happen. This is called the “Overshoot” and the more overshoot there is, the more distortion there is of the sound. The time it takes for the speaker to complete it’s overshoot and begin returning to the desired amplitude is called the “Peak Time.” We want this time to be as short as possible. Now the speaker careens back toward the Desired Amplitude, but it’ll pass it and be brought back again. It’ll do this a few times until it actually lands at the right voltage on average. The time it takes the cone to achieve this reasonable average is called the “Settling Time.”
The problem is, this was a spike, not an extended tone as expressed in the image above. So what happens is the spike happens, and by the time the cone
is heading toward the Desired Amplitude, the voltage stops, and the cone is drawn back toward its rest position again. It never reaches the voltage’s desired position for it. The physical cone just can’t react that fast. Anything which can’t immediately follow the voltage perfectly is distorting the sound of your system. Of course, we’re used to hearing this kind of thing in this culture, because speakers have this kind of error. But make no mistake, it’s something that we want present in our listening environment in an infinitesmal way.
You can immediately see that we want speakers which have a super short rise time, short overshoot, short peak time, and dead short settle time.
Wait. What Happens If My Speakers Have Bad Transient Response?
FIrst, speakers with bad transient response have to be turned up more than others. Why? Because none of the volume peaks of the sound can be reproduced. It’s like having a built in limiter on your system. As a result your overall volume may represent a level which is inaccurate – which as we’ve talked about in other articles on this blog, is the difference between a good mix for your venue and a crummy one.
Second, because you’re cutting off peaks from all frequencies, anything which you need to “snap” or “punch” will sound “flubby” and lethargic – including dialog. The result is always to overcompensate with EQ, compression and automation. I’ve heard these mixes in theaters where every line of dialog, sfx and foley sound is like a knife in your skull. After a while, the audience has no emotional dynamics in the film, and they just get numb.
Lastly, bad transient response in a speaker is rarely a uniform situation. Usually, the louder the volume, the worse the response. As a result, low volume mixes sound better than higher volume moments. While having soft sections feel less “spikey” than loud moments might be a good dramatic plan, I’d rather have choice in the matter – than expect my mix sounds uniform throughout.
How Can I Tell If They Have Good Transient Response?
Sadly, I can’t think of a single speaker manufacturer which displays transient response characteristics of their speakers. It takes manual observation.
The best way to do it is take a series of sound effect transients and mash them into 10 in a row into an audio file. Something REALLY transient. Gun Shot

SFX are usually bad, because they’ve been processed. I’m talking about using Adobe Audition to create a 1ms, -12 dB blast of pink noise every 5 seconds for 30 seconds. That’ll do it. Go to Guitar Center, or wherever you can audition your speaker in question. Plug your iPhone into it. No it doesn’t need to be great fidelity from your iPhone. Then turn the speaker up to about 100 dB at about 6 ft from you. You can literally watch what the woofer is doing. Does it look like nothing is happening or does it flub back and forth visually after the blast? Can you hear the “snap” of the audio cutting in, or is it sort of a micro-short fade in? Is there a good snap at the end of the audio blast? You should be able to hear two very close together snaps from audio in to audio out of the blast? What you’re doing is the most brutal thing anyone can do to a speaker. Leaving it at rest and then blasting it with a strong volume full bandwidth (pink noise). If it can reproduce this even remotely well, you’ve got a contender. The guys at Guitar Center will think you’re nutz, though.
You also want to make sure you’re listening in various frequency ranges. A speaker may have a great tweeter response, but a lousy woofer response. In the case of the good old Mackie HR 8-24s (ebay only), it had killer transient response…until it got below 60 Hz, and then it was like a slug. Why? Because the good folks at Mackie decided to sacrifice transient response on the low-low end for actually hearing it at all in a small sized speaker. They took the entire back of the speaker cabinet and made a passive woofer which responded to super low frequencies after the woofer reacted. As a result, you had an incredibly low frequency response down to 37 Hz or so, but forget anything snappy happening down there. It afforded the user the ability to hear sustained lows, however, which were ideal for anything but cinema or pop/beat oriented music. I owned a pair forever.
What Nearfield Studio Speakers Do You Recommend? Full disclosure, Harman is a sponsor of Cinema Sound, but I’d never push a product which had anything less than a 100 CS rating even if it were a sponsor product.
Under $500 each:
JBL LSR 305
Tannoy NFM8 (ebay only now)
Over $1,250 each:
Anything Tannoy
Genelec 1032A
Presonus S8
Notice the break in price from $500-$1,250? Yeah. There’s a good reason for that. Not because there aren’t good speakers at that price point, but because I have never worked with speakers in that price range with holistically good transient response. Are there other speakers you think are super snappy? Let us know! I’m also rating speakers which I’ve personally used for Cinema Mixing. Music? totally a different beast.
Hopefully, now that you’ve gotten the gist of why Transient Response is critical, you’ll go and get yourself some dope speaker digs. Your media deserves it and so do you.
Have your own success and failures with studio monitors? Let us know or Tweet about it!